Get results by email
The trials · Oct 16, 2026

Our tests: same room, real results

Overall so far (2 tests): RoomsGPT is the most consistent across both tests (1st on the empty room, tied 2nd on the furnished bedroom). Reimagine Home is strongest on the furnished room. Paintit varies (2nd on the empty room, 4th on the bedroom).

Test 1 · Oct 16, 2026

Empty room staging

Photo: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet). Prompt: Living Room + Scandinavian. Original photo: CC0, StockSnap. Ranked by faithfulness to the original room. No numeric scores, just what we saw.

  1. #1RoomsGPT
  2. #2Paintit.ai
  3. #3REimagineHome
Original photo for test 1: empty room staging: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
Original photo

Summary

RankToolLoginTimeWatermarkOutput
1RoomsGPTNo login~15sSmall watermark1920×1408
2Paintit.aiEmail signup required (despite 'no signup' claim)~60sLarge watermark1360×1024
3REimagineHomeEmail link signup~30sLattice watermark2368×1776
3Spacely AIEmail signup + verification~40sCorner logo watermark1448×1086
5HomeDesignsAINo loginFastNo watermark640×512
6HomestylerEmail code signup~25–30sSmall logo watermarkScreenshot crop (download is members-only on free plan; paid from $6.80/mo, per homestyler.com/pricing, checked Oct 16, 2026)
7AI HomeDesignEmail signup with 6-digit code (no card)~17s+ (site estimates 15s)'AI HomeDesign' watermark bottom-right (no-watermark download is paid)1633×1225
8MeltFlexEmail code login required (despite claim)~30–40sTiled watermark1200×896

Before and after, drag each slider

Original: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
RoomsGPT result for test 1: empty room staging

#1Faithfulness rank · Test 1

RoomsGPT

Best at keeping the original room.

Login
No login
Time
~15s
Watermark
Small watermark
Output
1920×1408
Original: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
Paintit.ai result for test 1: empty room staging

#2Faithfulness rank · Test 1

Paintit.ai

Kept the room well. One image cost 8 of 30 free credits.

Login
Email signup required (despite 'no signup' claim)
Time
~60s
Watermark
Large watermark
Output
1360×1024
Original: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
REimagineHome result for test 1: empty room staging

#3Faithfulness rank · Test 1

REimagineHome

Shifted perspective. 5 free designs.

Login
Email link signup
Time
~30s
Watermark
Lattice watermark
Output
2368×1776
Original: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
Spacely AI result for test 1: empty room staging

#3Faithfulness rank · Test 1

Spacely AI

Convincing furnishing, but walls/geometry shifted, concrete floor covered by a rug, outlet hidden; window kept. First Auto Furnish free, then 5 credits each (50 credits after signup bonus).

Login
Email signup + verification
Time
~40s
Watermark
Corner logo watermark
Output
1448×1086
Original: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
HomeDesignsAI result for test 1: empty room staging

#5Faithfulness rank · Test 1

HomeDesignsAI

Changed the room layout a lot.

Login
No login
Time
Fast
Watermark
No watermark
Output
640×512
Original: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
Homestyler result for test 1: empty room staging

#6Faithfulness rank · Test 1

Homestyler

Concrete became wood floor, window moved, perspective changed, outlet kept. Free trial generation, then 10 credits each.

Login
Email code signup
Time
~25–30s
Watermark
Small logo watermark
Output
Screenshot crop (download is members-only on free plan; paid from $6.80/mo, per homestyler.com/pricing, checked Oct 16, 2026)
Original: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
AI HomeDesign result for test 1: empty room staging

#7Faithfulness rank · Test 1

AI HomeDesign

Poor preservation: walls and ceiling covered in beige diamond wallpaper, ceiling made vaulted, window kept but redrawn, perspective roughly kept but warped/cluttered, concrete floor covered by a jute rug, outlet gone. Virtual Staging mode; 1 credit per image, 5 free left after this one.

Login
Email signup with 6-digit code (no card)
Time
~17s+ (site estimates 15s)
Watermark
'AI HomeDesign' watermark bottom-right (no-watermark download is paid)
Output
1633×1225
Original: Empty white room (right-wall window, concrete floor, left-wall outlet)
MeltFlex result for test 1: empty room staging

#8Faithfulness rank · Test 1

MeltFlex

Turned it into a different room. Worst result.

Login
Email code login required (despite claim)
Time
~30–40s
Watermark
Tiled watermark
Output
1200×896
Test 2 · Oct 16, 2026

Furnished bedroom redesign

Photo: Furnished bedroom (bed, left nightstand with plant, book and lamp, backpack, window, dark hardwood with sun patches). Prompt: Bedroom, Modern, redesign keeping the structure. Original photo: CC0, StockSnap. Ranked by faithfulness to the original room. No numeric scores, just what we saw.

  1. #1REimagineHome
  2. #2RoomsGPT
  3. #2Spacely AI
Original photo for test 2: furnished bedroom redesign: Furnished bedroom (bed, left nightstand with plant, book and lamp, backpack, window, dark hardwood with sun patches)
Original photo

Summary

RankToolLoginTimeWatermarkOutput
1REimagineHomeEmail link signup~30–45sDiagonal lattice watermark plus badge2496×1664
2RoomsGPTNo login~12sRoomsGPT.io badge watermark (clean download is Plus at $4.99/mo)1920×1280
2Spacely AIEmail signup + verification~45–50sSPACELY AI logo watermark1536×1024
4Paintit.aiEmail signup required~40–60sNo watermark seen this time1360×1024 (4:3, input was 3:2)

Before and after, drag each slider

Original: Furnished bedroom (bed, left nightstand with plant, book and lamp, backpack, window, dark hardwood with sun patches)
REimagineHome result for test 2: furnished bedroom redesign

#1Faithfulness rank · Test 2

REimagineHome

Best structure preservation in this test. Bed kept (headboard removed); nightstand kept and restyled; window sliver and lamp kept; corner exact; hardwood and sun patches kept; perspective kept. Chat prompt; 1 credit used, 3 free left.

Login
Email link signup
Time
~30–45s
Watermark
Diagonal lattice watermark plus badge
Output
2496×1664
Original: Furnished bedroom (bed, left nightstand with plant, book and lamp, backpack, window, dark hardwood with sun patches)
RoomsGPT result for test 2: furnished bedroom redesign

#2Faithfulness rank · Test 2

RoomsGPT

Strong style change. Kept the left nightstand (plus plant, book, lamp, backpack), the window, the corner and the perspective. Bed in the same spot, but its look was replaced and the headboard narrower. A large rug covers most of the hardwood. Added a second nightstand on the right.

Login
No login
Time
~12s
Watermark
RoomsGPT.io badge watermark (clean download is Plus at $4.99/mo)
Output
1920×1280
Original: Furnished bedroom (bed, left nightstand with plant, book and lamp, backpack, window, dark hardwood with sun patches)
Spacely AI result for test 2: furnished bedroom redesign

#2Faithfulness rank · Test 2

Spacely AI

Bed kept very closely, including the headboard; nightstand kept and restyled; corner exact; perspective kept. Hardwood replaced with pale planks; backpack recolored rather than removed. Creative Interior preset, Bedroom/Modern; 10 credits per image.

Login
Email signup + verification
Time
~45–50s
Watermark
SPACELY AI logo watermark
Output
1536×1024
Original: Furnished bedroom (bed, left nightstand with plant, book and lamp, backpack, window, dark hardwood with sun patches)
Paintit.ai result for test 2: furnished bedroom redesign

#4Faithfulness rank · Test 2

Paintit.ai

Bed roughly kept but framing tighter; nightstand kept and restyled; window turned into a horizontal band and a picture was added; corner kept but framing shifted; dark hardwood and sun patch kept; perspective slightly reframed. Chat prompt (no room or style selectors); 8 credits per image.

Login
Email signup required
Time
~40–60s
Watermark
No watermark seen this time
Output
1360×1024 (4:3, input was 3:2)
Not tested in test 2: HomeDesignsAI: Not tested in test 2: HomeDesignsAI now requires login (email, Google or Facebook) to generate. It was no-login in test 1.

Could not test

BlockedCollov AICould not test: signup bug. Email verification accepts the code but never creates the account (tried twice on Oct 16, 2026).BlockedAiHouseNot tested: requires Google/Facebook login.BlockedDecorAICould not test without a card: the site advertises '3 Free Designs', but Generate opens a trial that becomes $24/month (plans $24/mo, $120/6 months, $240/year). We stopped before entering a card; there was no free generation without starting a trial (Oct 16, 2026).

Not tested yet

CoohomIKEA KreativInterior AIMNML AIPlanner 5DRemodel AIRoomGPTRoomStagingViewra